FREE Shipping & Insurance on U.S. orders over $10k. Flat $25 for orders below $10k
Every coin we offer is authenticated by top-tier grading services like PCGS, NGC, and CAC, so you can collect or invest with full confidence. From pre‑1933 U.S. gold to key-date silver dollars, we help you discover rare pieces that carry both historical meaning and tangible value all with transparent guidance and no sales pressure.
At P&F Coin Company, we specialize in purchasing rare, historic, and certified U.S. coins from single heirlooms to complete collections. Whether you’ve inherited a box of old coins, are refining your portfolio, or simply want a fair, no-pressure offer, we’re here to help.
As Alabama’s leading rare coin dealer, we offer top market payouts, fast evaluations, and expert guidance backed by decades of numismatic experience.
We buy a wide range of rare and certified U.S. coins, including:
Pre-1933 U.S. Gold Coins
Liberty Head, Indian Head, and Saint-Gaudens designs in all denominations
Early Federal Coinage
Half cents, large cents, early silver (1792–1836), and seated designs
U.S. Type Coins
A full spectrum of copper, nickel, silver, and gold coins from various series
Certified Coins
Coins graded by PCGS, NGC, and CAC, including key dates, mint errors, and high-population rarities
U.S. Paper Money
Legal tender notes, silver certificates, large-size currency, and obsolete banknotes
Attractively Toned Coins & Eye Appeal Pieces
Especially those with strong strike, luster, and unique visual qualities
We’re known for our knowledge and appreciation of coins with strong eye appeal, whether they’re brilliantly toned, sharply struck, or simply rare.
Grading determines a coin’s condition, value, and market trust. That’s why all our rare coins are professionally certified by PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service), NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company), or CAC (Certified Acceptance Corporation). These independent organizations inspect each coin’s strike, luster, surface preservation, and rarity assigning a grade that reflects its true standing in the collector world. If grading terms feel confusing, we’re happy to walk you through it with no jargon, no rush.
Expert Appraisal
Our team includes experienced numismatists who specialize in U.S. coins, from colonial issues to modern rarities. You’ll get real market-based insight not guesswork.
Transparent Offers
We explain how we value each coin considering grading, condition, rarity, and recent auction trends. No games, no confusion.
Top Dollar Paid
We offer high payouts on both certified coins and raw collections without the lowball tactics you’ll find elsewhere.
Safe, Secure Transactions
Whether in person or by mail, your coins are handled with the highest standards of care and security.
No Pressure
Appraisals are always free. You’ll never be pushed to sell even if we’ve spent time evaluating your collection.
Visit our store during business hours or set up a private consultation for larger or high-value collections.
Our experts will examine your coins and explain the grading, market factors, and what makes them valuable.
We’ll give you a fair, written offer on the spot. Accept it, and you’ll be paid immediately via check, cash (as permitted), or bank transfer.
Many people aren’t sure whether their old coins or inherited collections are valuable and that’s exactly what we’re here for. We often uncover significant pieces hiding in family boxes or mixed bags.
If available, please bring any certifications (PCGS, NGC, CAC), original packaging, or provenance documents. These can significantly enhance the value of your collection.
Whether you’re browsing for your first piece or refining a long-term collection, we’re here to answer your questions with no pressure and expert support every step of the way
Stop by our Alabaster, AL store, or contact us to schedule an appraisal.